Derniers sujets
CSC2012 Feedback
4 participants
Compet' [CFT] :: CSC 2012 :: La buvette
Page 1 sur 1
CSC2012 Feedback
!!Attention!! Wall of text incomming
but please read it. I tried to keep the sentences easy, so maybe google translator can get the main idea
Hey all admins and supporters of CSC!
First of all I wanted to say thanks for the whole competition. It was a pleasure for me to take part and a honor to win it
Next I wanted to give you a little feedback for next years edition.
1. unnkown maps-mode
yes it is unusual to drive matches on unnkown maps, but I like it and overall it is that what makes this cup unique. So if you can, please keep it up.
But this mode also brings a few problems.
Because when you watch other matches, you can also get to know the tracks driven in this match.
Sadly I came into this situation too. In 2 very deciding matches even: In Quarter final against gswe81 I knew the first 2 maps from watching a 1/8 final the day before and in the grand final I knew the first 2 and the very last track that wasn't driven, as I watched parts of the small final.
In fact that gave me one more warm up round on these maps and it felt pretty unfair. But I just came randomly into this situation and other drivers told me that they came into the same situation.
And this problem becomes even bigger when someone wants to use it for cheating. Overall I trust the dirt community that they won't do that, but as you know there are always a few suspicious individuals :/
That's why I would prefer to have special maps atleast from ¼ or better from 1/8 finals already.
Moreover it would be perfect if the matches could be at the same time, or atleast several of them, so that in those matches the same tracks can be driven. Of course that's not nice for the spectators but I think it would make the whole cup being more fair.
2. tracks itself
Of course people were complaining about the tracks, as they always do, in all competitions.
But in my opinion they were pretty nice overall. Because for me the most important thing about a matchtrack is that it is fair and bugfree.
And atleast the tracks that I drove had just a few minorbugs and were even better than several NDC-tracks for example.
On top of that they had changing styles (some were technical, some more speedy).
And all that by one single person is just awesome! Really good job here Auliv!
3. match mode
well, to be honest I think this could be improved a bit.
3 points per map are bit short, especially in the matches with only 3 tracks.
You just need to be a bit unlucky to get 2 bugs in 2 runs(which can always happen, on all tracks) and you are already down by 2:0 and the track is nearly lost for you. Especially in a 3-track-match that can decide the whole match.
Maybe it would be better in this case to race until 5 or 7 points, which could also lead into more intensive matches.
4. Cup mode
Overall I really liked the classical layout of this cup:
1 week time attack to qualify
groupstage → knockout stage
But I had the feeling that until 1/16 final there were many very uneven matches that were not very attractive to watch.
But I also have to admit that I don't know a better solution which could work with the system of unnkown tracks and the participation of such many drivers.
5. homepage
I really liked your homepage and I appreciate that you tried to write the rules and all other important messages in english.
Nevertheless there were still several important messages concerning matchdates or number of maps for example, that were only written in french and not easy to understand for international drivers.
(Firefox listed google Translator over the last few weeks always as one of my most clicked websites )
These were a few thoughts I had throughout this cup and that came up in discussions with several other drivers. I hope it can help you a bit with the plannings for future editions.
Keep your great work up and if possible, even improve it.
All in all I really liked the whole competition and I am already looking forward for the next edition!
With best regards,
Speed u need
but please read it. I tried to keep the sentences easy, so maybe google translator can get the main idea
Hey all admins and supporters of CSC!
First of all I wanted to say thanks for the whole competition. It was a pleasure for me to take part and a honor to win it
Next I wanted to give you a little feedback for next years edition.
1. unnkown maps-mode
yes it is unusual to drive matches on unnkown maps, but I like it and overall it is that what makes this cup unique. So if you can, please keep it up.
But this mode also brings a few problems.
Because when you watch other matches, you can also get to know the tracks driven in this match.
Sadly I came into this situation too. In 2 very deciding matches even: In Quarter final against gswe81 I knew the first 2 maps from watching a 1/8 final the day before and in the grand final I knew the first 2 and the very last track that wasn't driven, as I watched parts of the small final.
In fact that gave me one more warm up round on these maps and it felt pretty unfair. But I just came randomly into this situation and other drivers told me that they came into the same situation.
And this problem becomes even bigger when someone wants to use it for cheating. Overall I trust the dirt community that they won't do that, but as you know there are always a few suspicious individuals :/
That's why I would prefer to have special maps atleast from ¼ or better from 1/8 finals already.
Moreover it would be perfect if the matches could be at the same time, or atleast several of them, so that in those matches the same tracks can be driven. Of course that's not nice for the spectators but I think it would make the whole cup being more fair.
2. tracks itself
Of course people were complaining about the tracks, as they always do, in all competitions.
But in my opinion they were pretty nice overall. Because for me the most important thing about a matchtrack is that it is fair and bugfree.
And atleast the tracks that I drove had just a few minorbugs and were even better than several NDC-tracks for example.
On top of that they had changing styles (some were technical, some more speedy).
And all that by one single person is just awesome! Really good job here Auliv!
3. match mode
well, to be honest I think this could be improved a bit.
3 points per map are bit short, especially in the matches with only 3 tracks.
You just need to be a bit unlucky to get 2 bugs in 2 runs(which can always happen, on all tracks) and you are already down by 2:0 and the track is nearly lost for you. Especially in a 3-track-match that can decide the whole match.
Maybe it would be better in this case to race until 5 or 7 points, which could also lead into more intensive matches.
4. Cup mode
Overall I really liked the classical layout of this cup:
1 week time attack to qualify
groupstage → knockout stage
But I had the feeling that until 1/16 final there were many very uneven matches that were not very attractive to watch.
But I also have to admit that I don't know a better solution which could work with the system of unnkown tracks and the participation of such many drivers.
5. homepage
I really liked your homepage and I appreciate that you tried to write the rules and all other important messages in english.
Nevertheless there were still several important messages concerning matchdates or number of maps for example, that were only written in french and not easy to understand for international drivers.
(Firefox listed google Translator over the last few weeks always as one of my most clicked websites )
These were a few thoughts I had throughout this cup and that came up in discussions with several other drivers. I hope it can help you a bit with the plannings for future editions.
Keep your great work up and if possible, even improve it.
All in all I really liked the whole competition and I am already looking forward for the next edition!
With best regards,
Speed u need
SPEED U NEED- Messages : 31
Date d'inscription : 17/07/2012
Re: CSC2012 Feedback
Merci SPEED
Toutes tes remarques sont pertinentes.
Nous en tiendrons compte pour l'année prochaine.
----------------------------------------------------
SPEED thank you !
All your comments are appropriate.
We will consider it for next year.
Toutes tes remarques sont pertinentes.
Nous en tiendrons compte pour l'année prochaine.
----------------------------------------------------
SPEED thank you !
All your comments are appropriate.
We will consider it for next year.
Auliv'- Admin
- Messages : 271
Date d'inscription : 11/05/2011
Age : 50
Localisation : Haute Normandie
Re: CSC2012 Feedback
Thanks speed.
Mais keskidi??
Mais keskidi??
Hanni- Admin
- Messages : 60
Date d'inscription : 11/05/2011
Age : 53
Re: CSC2012 Feedback
Hanni a écrit:Thanks speed.
Mais keskidi??
A première vue, j'ai rien capté mais Google translation, mon ami m'aidé.
Auliv'- Admin
- Messages : 271
Date d'inscription : 11/05/2011
Age : 50
Localisation : Haute Normandie
Re: CSC2012 Feedback
Si mauvais que ça en anglais les gars? xDDDD
It's nice to see that players want to make a bether competition =D And I agree with Spped but I think it will be hard to have new maps for all new rounds =/ It make too much maps =(
But I think that this competition is magical and it will stay my think =D
Love you CFT (and Spped too^^) <3
PS : Désolé si l'anglais est très mauvais mais je préfère assumer mes fautes et puis pour des français ça peut que être compréhensible xD
Hop bisous <3<3
It's nice to see that players want to make a bether competition =D And I agree with Spped but I think it will be hard to have new maps for all new rounds =/ It make too much maps =(
But I think that this competition is magical and it will stay my think =D
Love you CFT (and Spped too^^) <3
PS : Désolé si l'anglais est très mauvais mais je préfère assumer mes fautes et puis pour des français ça peut que être compréhensible xD
Hop bisous <3<3
Grr!! Nico- Messages : 34
Date d'inscription : 11/08/2012
Compet' [CFT] :: CSC 2012 :: La buvette
Page 1 sur 1
Permission de ce forum:
Vous ne pouvez pas répondre aux sujets dans ce forum
|
|
Mar 27 Nov - 17:53 par Grr!! Nico
» Merci à Tous !
Mar 27 Nov - 17:42 par Grr!! Nico
» Grande Finale : da¢SP´SPEED U NEEDシ / ווו.Nico
Jeu 15 Nov - 15:31 par nico~17~
» Classement Final !
Jeu 15 Nov - 8:02 par Auliv'
» Petite Finale : 'ηψт' Manu / 'ηψт' Wiidii
Mer 14 Nov - 18:16 par Auliv'
» TM Live
Mer 14 Nov - 18:11 par Auliv'
» Match 29 : 'ηψт' Manu / da¢SP´SPEED U NEEDシ
Jeu 8 Nov - 16:23 par SPEED U NEED
» Match 30 : i 'ηψт'WiiDii / ווו.Nico
Mer 7 Nov - 21:54 par Auliv'
» Les Plaintes
Mer 7 Nov - 20:30 par Grr!! Nico